China - Vilagum Thirai - A Book Review

Recently I read this book – “China – Vilagum Thirai”. This is the translation of the much acclaimed book 'Smoke and Mirrors' by Pallavi Aiyar. This is translated (in Tamil) by Raman Raja and Kizhakku Pathippagam has published this book (Price Rs 200; pages 350).

Pallavi – a journalist, has stayed in China for 5 years and travelled the length and breadth of the country, met different set of people from businessmen to saints, lived in one of the old type settlements (Hudong) in Beijing and mingled with the local people as one among them. This experience gives her the insights normally missed by the standard travellers and their travellogues. This book is more about China in the eyes of an Indian, so it is easy for us to understand about this Marxist Country.

Here are the salient points from this book.

• Though you can see poor people in rural China – they lead a better life compared to similar economically challanged people in India; It is not an exaggeration to say that the Govt of China has made them live a gracious life.
• Govt’s iron hand is visible in all places – people think what Govt wants them to think.
• Apparently Chinese people have a confused sense of patriotism and dissent – they consider dissent is not good – whatsoever and they toe the govt drawn line.
• People cannot settle from villages to cities – they have to obtain inland permit (something like passport called as “Hukou System”) and then move. Else, they will be sent back to their village if caught by the police; this is the reason why they do not have slums in Beijing and in other large cities.
• When a journalist meets a religious head/businessman/professor – a Chinese govt appointed person will follow the journalist. The guest cannot say anything that they think in their mind.
• Any dissent will be viewed seriously by the Govt – they will be arrested and put behind bars
• Ordinary Chinese people are not bothered about the type of work they perform – that is just an avenue to earn a living; they are proud of doing any work.
• Related to this is; there is no caste system in the country – Marxists act tough on religious activities – so no question of caste. This means – a person who is cleaning road/toilet, will not be identified and picked by birth. He may work today cleaning toilets, tomorrow he may be a businessman or something like that. He is not identified by the work he is doing.
• Tibetans resent Chinese interference – but cannot help it – when China sets its eye on Tibet.
• Religious freedom is allowed as long as it does not question/comment/feedback anything the govt does.
• If Govt wants a piece of land – buildings, farm lands will be demolished after issuing notice. Owners will be given a pittance and they cannot go to court.
• Personal productivity of a Chinese labourer is better than Indian labourer.
• Coruption is rampant – but not the type of corruption you see in India but the types you see in the US and other developed countries. If they have to build a bridge – they will build and take some money from that; not like do crappy stuff and swindle all the money.
• Govt encourages businesses big time and people have sort of given up worrying about the govt – they are busy making money. This generation in China is apathetic to politics (like any other country’s younger generation) and they are only bothered about their own growth.
• Lots of foreigners including people from India move there to China and start Yoga schools, work in hotels, buying products wholesale, etc.

The book is an interesting read for anyone who wants to know about China. The book maintains the interest in the reader throughout. One thing is certain – Raman Raja has done a wonderful work translating this book – you do not get a feeling that you are reading a translated book at all.

I recommend this book for anyone who wants to know about China.